Wednesday, 24th of October, 2007
OiNK oinks no more (8:50 am)
I've been musing since yesterday over the demise of private BitTorrent site OiNK, and especially of the rather forbidding message now hosted there ("A criminal investigation continues into the identities and activities of the site's users"). In particular, I was thinking how this criminal investigation, if it finds anyone much, is going to turn up a huge selection of massive music fans with huge CD & vinyl collections, and what's more a huge selection of professional musicians and DJs. Because many, many musos, and probably all DJs, are obsessive music fans.
I was going to write something up about it, about how despite its rather insanely huge selections, once I was able to check out its wares (well, its warez), I didn't find much that I wanted, because I'm such a completist anyway; and about how most of the music I've "stolen" from filesharing over the years now exists on my CD/vinyl shelves anyway — eventually I'll find a way of buying a physical copy of anything I like, and what, in the end, is the difference between a second-hand copy of an out-of-print item and a downloaded mp3 of the same, from the record company's point of view? (Answer: nothing. The fuckerz really hate second-hand record stores too!)
And the strange morality of OiNK was something that struck me very much – enforced sharing ratios, enforced sound quality, stringent rules about formatting and information supplied; could I square that in my head with the illegality of the whole exercise? I'm not sure. Even the fact that it was forbidden to share leaked pre-masters and studio sessions, which in a weird way was actually reassuring.
In any case, the wonderful Jace Clayton aka DJ /rupture has written the perfect post on the matter, so go read DEFENDING THE PIG: OiNK croaks. Thanks Jace!
3 Responses to “OiNK oinks no more”
Check the sidebar for archive links!
Utility Fog, Peter's show on FBi Radio in Sydney.
Raven, Peter's solo music.
FourPlay String Quartet, Peter's band.
Peter has a LiveGerbil, too! Friend me if you know me, but don't expect many posts there.
rss2, rss or atom feeds. Tasty!
Via those feeds, Stumblings is syndicated over @ LiveJournal if you want to add it to your friends list - but please come over here to leave comments (I don't check 'em there!)
Sidebar all too much? Check out all reviews separately in the:
Reading archives | Listening archives
Other weblogs of note:
poison to the mind
the null device
virulent memes (which is no more)
the lexicon, for the lovely lexi's lexcellent & lexstatic, um, music reviews :)
charlie stross's diary
chris lawson et al's talking squid
Roger Langridge's hotel fred
My Amazon.co.uk wishlist
Login if you're, like, the author or something
Comments RSS 2.0
30 queries. 0.489 seconds. Powered by WordPress |